Haven Practice Solutions
Money

Open Enrollment Season: How To Think About Insurance Credentialing In The Fourth Quarter

An October and November calendar with checkmarks, insurance cards, and autumn leaves
The short answer

Credentialing commonly takes 90 to 180 days, so a panel you apply to in the fall may not be active until winter or spring. Prepare your CAQH profile, collect your documents, choose panels that match your niche, and plan cash flow for the wait. Open enrollment changes plans and networks for many clients.

Key takeaways
  • Credentialing commonly takes months, so an application filed in the fourth quarter often yields approval and billing in the new year.
  • Open enrollment changes what clients ask for. Many people reassess coverage in the fall.
  • Choose panels deliberately by looking at who your ideal clients carry, what the plans pay, and what the contract requires.
  • Keep your CAQH profile complete and re attested, since an out of date profile is a leading cause of delay.

Every fall, therapists ask me the same question: should I start credentialing now, with the holidays coming, or wait until January? The honest answer is that waiting usually costs you more than starting. But the fourth quarter has its own quirks, and knowing them turns a slow, confusing process into a manageable one.

Why timing matters

Credentialing is the process insurance companies use to verify your license, education, training, malpractice coverage, and work history before they let you join their network. It commonly takes a few months from a complete application, and sometimes longer. During that time you generally cannot bill that payer as an in network provider.

That means an application you submit in October often leads to approval around the turn of the year or later. If you wait to begin until January, you may not see your first insurance client until spring or summer.

Open enrollment and what it means for your practice

In the fall, many people choose or reconsider their health coverage. Employers run open enrollment, the federal marketplace enrollment period generally begins in November, and Medicare's annual enrollment period runs in the fall. Some people also look for care before deductibles reset in the new year, or, once a deductible has been met, they use remaining benefits before the year ends.

For you, that creates two practical effects:

  • Clients ask more insurance questions. Be ready with a clear answer about which plans you accept and your out of network options.
  • Plan changes in January can alter who is in network. Existing clients may switch plans, and new clients may arrive with a plan you have not joined.

Choose your panels deliberately

Do not apply to every plan. Each panel adds paperwork, rate constraints, and administrative work. Pick a short list based on data.

  1. Ask who your ideal clients carry. Talk to local clinicians, referral partners, and employers. Note which plans appear most often.
  2. Check each plan's behavioral health network. Is it open or closed in your area? Some networks are full and close to new clinicians. Ask the payer's provider relations team.
  3. Compare rates and terms. Request the fee schedule for the codes you use and read the contract, including termination terms, audit rights, and cancellation limits.
  4. Consider the administrative load. Some payers are easier to work with than others. Ask colleagues about claim speed, denials, and support.
  5. Start with two or three. Add more once you have a rhythm.

Your credentialing toolkit

ItemNotes
Active, unrestricted licenseConfirm that your license type is accepted by the payer.
NPIFree through the national registry.
EIN or tax ID and W 9Match your legal business name and address exactly.
Professional liability insuranceMany payers require minimum coverage limits and a current certificate.
CAQH ProView profileComplete, authorized for the payers you apply to, and re attested on schedule.
Education and training recordsDiplomas, transcripts, and supervised experience documentation.
Work historyA clear timeline with no unexplained gaps.
Practice address and phoneConsistent across every application.

CAQH, in plain words

CAQH ProView is an online database where you store your credentialing information once and authorize payers to view it. Most payers rely on it. You must keep it current and re attest to its accuracy regularly, generally every 120 days. If your attestation lapses, a payer may pause or reject your application. Put the attestation date in your calendar the day you complete it.

A fourth quarter timeline

WhenDo this
Early OctoberChoose panels, complete your CAQH profile, and gather documents.
Mid OctoberSubmit applications and note submission dates and reference numbers.
NovemberFollow up politely every two to three weeks. Respond to requests the same day.
DecemberKeep following up. Offices may run slower around the holidays.
JanuaryConfirm effective dates, load rates into your billing system, and update your website and directories.

How to keep an application moving

  • Use a tracking spreadsheet: payer, date submitted, contact name, reference number, last follow up, status.
  • Answer requests immediately. Delays on your side stall everything.
  • Keep every confirmation, email, and phone note.
  • Ask for the effective date in writing. It determines which sessions you can bill.
  • Do not tell clients you are in network until you have confirmation and an effective date.

What to tell clients while you wait

You can offer self pay with a superbill for clients who have out of network benefits, in the meantime. Be clear that you are not yet in network, explain that reimbursement depends on their plan, provide a good faith estimate where required, and do not promise approval or timing.

Not sure about a payer rule?

Payer requirements, timelines, and fees change. Always confirm current details with the payer's provider relations team or provider manual before you sign or bill.

Is credentialing worth it for you?

It depends on your model, your market, and your values. For many new practices, a small set of panels helps fill a caseload and serves clients who rely on insurance. For others, self pay and sliding scale is a better fit. Run your numbers using your own rates and caseload goals before you start the process.

Credentialing rewards the people who start early, stay organized, and follow up kindly and often.

Walk through credentialing in the roadmap

Haven walks licensed therapists from "I think I want my own practice" to a first client, one clear step at a time. It is free to start and no card is needed.

Walk through credentialing in the roadmap

Found this useful? Share it with a therapist who is building a practice.

Common questions

How long does insurance credentialing take?

It commonly takes a few months from a complete application, and sometimes longer. Timelines vary by payer.

Should I start credentialing in the fall or wait until January?

Starting in the fall is usually better. An application submitted in October often leads to approval around the turn of the year or later, whereas waiting until January may push approval into spring or summer.

How often do I need to re attest in CAQH?

Generally every 120 days. A lapsed attestation can pause or reject your application, so put the date in your calendar.

How many insurance panels should I join?

Start with two or three that your ideal clients actually carry, then add more once you have a rhythm.

Can I see insurance clients while my application is pending?

Not as an in network provider until you have a confirmed effective date. Some practices offer self pay with a superbill in the meantime, with clear disclosures.

What causes credentialing delays?

Incomplete or inconsistent information, an outdated CAQH profile, missing documents, name or address mismatches, and slow responses to payer requests.

Sources and further reading

Rules, fees, and deadlines change. Confirm anything that affects a decision with the office that publishes it.

Anthony Brown is Co founder of Haven and founder of Black Maverick Consulting, where he builds referral systems and small business operations.

Keep reading

Haven Practice Solutions provides education and business tools, not legal, tax, or clinical advice. Nothing here creates an attorney client, accountant client, or clinical relationship.